Out With Erin

Exploring the Beauty of YYC and Beyond

close reading

After seeing tweet after tweet, comment after comment, and picture after picture about the book “Falling in Love With Close Reading,” I decided I should follow the trend and purchase my own copy as well. I wanted to be included with all this twitter talk about the book! It arrived from Amazon quickly, and as I began to read, I’ve been thrilled by the ideas in this book. However, I often find when I read things they easily escape from my mind. I’m not the type to highlight a book, so I thought that perhaps blogging about it would give me a reference point, something to refer back to, for others to learn from as well, and maybe even start a conversation. So here we go…a summary beginning with chapters one and two.

What is close reading? (pg. 4)
Close reading is an interaction between the person reading the text and the text itself, that happens when one makes observations about what he/she has read and then interprets and develops a deeper understanding. It involves reading a section of a text over again, thinking about what was written and looking at it through several lenses. This knowledge can then be used throughout the whole text. In other words, looking at the little details to develop an understanding of the bigger picture.

Students need to be taught these skills and how to read through a critical lens. It is important that teachers show students these steps, and teach close reading instruction in a meaningful way. Instruction based on close reading should (pg. 5):
– be engaging
– promote student independence
– fit within other aspects of reading instruction, it isn’t the be all end all
– allow for time for students to reread sections and practice the skills learned
– be designed in a way that integrates easily with students needs and abilities

When students read books or a piece of text and then respond (whether it be written, oral, or through questioning), they have an idea or question to answer and then look for information or evidence to support their belief. This limits their thinking and simplifies it. Close reading instead, encourages students to gather and organize all that information and then develop their idea from the evidence they have (pg. 12). Here is how that looks through a chart the others present in the appendix of their book.

Picture taken from pg. 126, Falling in Love With Close Reading

Picture taken from pg. 126, Falling in Love With Close Reading

In the book they provide a fantastic example of what this would look like, through the story Out of My Mind. Through this example it was demonstrated how a student’s initial, simple idea about a character has now become deeper, much more complex, and allows students to have a better understanding.

Step 2 in the chart is the key area, where students look for patterns and connect ideas together. This is where the understanding begins, and as students reread, look back, and develop new ideas via using patterning, it allows the student to develop a much clearer understanding of the story or text. Below is an example from the book as to what this could look like.

Figure 2.8: Ways to Revise Our Thinking, from Falling in Love With Close Reading, pg. 28

Figure 2.8: Ways to Revise Our Thinking, from Falling in Love With Close Reading, pg. 28

The ideas covered in these two chapters are a teachers dream. This appears to be an incredible way for students to develop a deep understanding of characters and things happening in a text they are reading. It causing them to think critically, go back and examine their initial thoughts, and develop new ideas. Although this seems like an easy task, I wonder how much modeling and “rehearsing” is needed in order to prepare students to take on such a task. At what point would the level of independence wanted, be gained? How does a teacher observe and encourage students without taking that independence away? How do you teach the skills for students to look for these connections and patterns on their own?

2 thoughts on “Falling in Love With Close Reading: Chapters 1/2

  1. Dawn says:

    Thanks for posting about this. I have been interested in the concept, but not enough to buy the book. I will hope for more posts on this so I can learn more!

    At first, when I heard about this, I thought it was basically what Open court teaches….only with novels? (I loved Out of My Mind, by the way)

    It is interesting because re-reading and thinking about a fiction book isn’t really something I ever do…..and I consider myself quite a prolific reader. I wonder if my reading experiences would be enriched if I stopped and did this myself with the books I read? I think I would have to start doing it before I could teach kids how to do it or see the value of it. Seems more like “classroom reading” to me…..which doesn’t always translate to real life or create children who really love reading. Am I wrong?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: